Welding cost calculation: weld metal, consumables and cost per metre
How to estimate welding cost: weld metal weight for fillet and V butt welds, rod or wire to buy, arc time, operating factor, gas and power, with a worked stick vs MIG example.
A fabrication quote often lives or dies on the welding line. Steel is easy to price by the kilogram, but welding is priced by time, and time is hard to see on a drawing. A welding cost calculation turns the weld sizes and lengths on the drawing into kilograms of weld metal, kilograms of rod or wire to buy, hours at the bench and, finally, a cost per metre of weld you can quote against. This guide walks through each step with the formulas, the typical values for stick, MIG/MAG, flux-cored and submerged arc welding, and a fully worked example that compares stick and MIG on the same 52 m of welds.
The five parts of a welding cost calculation
Every welding estimate, however detailed, is built from the same five pieces:
- Weld metal: how many kilograms of steel the joints need, from the cross-section and length of each weld.
- Consumable: how much rod or wire you must buy to put that weld metal down, because some of it never reaches the joint.
- Arc time: how long the arc must burn to deposit the weld metal, from the deposition rate of the process.
- Total time: the paid hours, which are much longer than the arc time because of fit-up, rod changes, cleaning and moving.
- Gas and power: shielding gas and electricity, both charged per hour of arc time.
The cost is then simply consumable × price, plus total time × labour rate, plus arc time × gas and power. The rest of this guide shows how to get each figure.
Step 1: weld cross-section and weld metal weight
The weight of a weld is its cross-sectional area times its length times the density of the metal:
m = A × L × ρ
- m = weld metal mass, kg
- A = cross-sectional area of the weld, m² (1 mm² = 10⁻⁶ m²)
- L = weld length, m
- ρ = density, 7,850 kg/m³ for carbon steel (stainless steel is about 7,900–8,000 kg/m³)
A handy shortcut: for carbon steel, every 1 mm² of cross-section weighs 7.85 g per metre of weld.
Fillet welds
An equal-leg fillet weld is a right-angled triangle. With leg length z, the theoretical area is:
A = z² / 2
Note that drawings may give the throat thickness a instead of the leg. For an equal-leg fillet, z = a × √2 ≈ 1.414 a, so a 5.6 mm throat is an 8 mm leg. Mixing the two up changes the weld weight by a factor of two.
Single-V butt welds
A single-V butt weld on plate thickness t, with root gap g and an included groove angle α (no root face), has the area of a rectangle (the gap) plus two triangles (the bevels):
A = g × t + t² × tan(α / 2)
For the common 60° groove, tan 30° = 0.577. Some estimating methods include a root face or a different gap convention, so check which one your welding procedure uses before comparing figures with a supplier.
The cap allowance and over-welding
Real welds are not flat. A fillet has a convex face and a butt weld has a cap and often a root bead, so estimators add an allowance. The welding cost calculator on this site adds 15% to the theoretical area, which is a reasonable figure for normal work:
A_design = A_theoretical × 1.15
The bigger risk is over-welding. Weld area grows with the square of the leg, so a welder who lays a 10 mm fillet where 8 mm was specified puts down (10 / 8)² = 1.56 times the metal: 56% more wire, gas and arc time for no extra strength the design asked for. On a real job this is often the largest single source of overrun.
Step 2: how much rod or wire to buy
Not all the consumable you buy ends up in the joint. Stick electrodes lose the stub end, the flux coating and spatter; wires lose a little spatter and the cut-off end. The ratio is the deposition efficiency:
Consumable to buy = m / η_d
Process | Typical deposition efficiency η_d | Typical operating factor |
|---|---|---|
Stick (SMAW) | 55–65% | 20–40% |
MIG/MAG solid wire (GMAW) | 90–98% | 30–50% manual, higher mechanised |
Flux-cored wire (FCAW) | 80–90% | 30–50% manual, higher mechanised |
Submerged arc (SAW) | about 99% (wire; flux is extra) | 50–90% mechanised |
The ranges are those quoted in welding trade literature and consumable makers' data. Stub length, spatter and shielding gas all move the figure, so use your own shop data if you have it. For SAW, remember to price the flux separately; it is consumed at roughly the same weight as the wire.
Step 3: arc time and total time
The deposition rate D is how many kilograms of weld metal the process lays down per hour of arc time. Arc time is then:
t_arc = m / D
But nobody welds for a full hour every hour. The operating factor (also called arc-on time or duty cycle in estimating) is the share of paid time the arc is actually burning. The rest goes on fit-up, tacking, changing rods, chipping slag, grinding and moving the work. Total paid time is:
t_total = t_arc / OF
The operating factor is the most powerful number in the estimate. Going from 30% to 40% cuts the labour hours by a quarter without anyone welding faster.
Deposition rate from wire feed speed
For wire processes you can work out the deposition rate yourself instead of relying on a table. The mass of wire per metre is its cross-section times density, so for a 1.2 mm steel wire:
wire mass = π / 4 × 1.2² mm² × 7.85 g/(mm²·m) = 8.88 g/m
At a wire feed speed of 8 m/min the melting rate is 8.88 × 8 × 60 = 4,262 g/h, about 4.26 kg/h. Multiplying by a 93% deposition efficiency gives a deposition rate of about 4.0 kg/h. Stick electrodes are slower; a few kilograms per hour is the upper end for normal manual work, and 1.5–2 kg/h is a common planning figure for medium electrodes.
Step 4: shielding gas and power
Gas and power are charged per hour of arc time, not per paid hour.
Gas per arc hour = flow (L/min) × 60 / 1,000 m³
MIG flow is typically set between 10 and 30 L/min depending on nozzle size and current; 15 L/min is 0.9 m³ per arc hour. Stick and self-shielded flux-cored welding use no gas.
Electrical input (kW) = V × I / (1,000 × η_ps)
where V is the arc voltage, I the welding current and η_ps the efficiency of the power source (inverters are often 80–90%). Multiply by the electricity tariff to get the cost per arc hour. It is usually the smallest item in the estimate.
Worked example: stick vs MIG on a steel frame
A carbon steel equipment frame needs 40 m of 8 mm fillet welds and 12 m of single-V butt welds on 12 mm plate (60° groove, 2 mm root gap), 52 m of weld in total. Labour and overhead cost 12 per hour (all costs are in plain currency units, so use your own). We compare stick welding with MIG.
Weld metal
- Fillet: A = 8² / 2 = 32 mm², × 1.15 = 36.8 mm² → 36.8 × 7.85 = 0.289 kg/m → 40 m × 0.289 = 11.56 kg
- Butt: A = 2 × 12 + 12² × 0.577 = 24 + 83.1 = 107.1 mm², × 1.15 = 123.2 mm² → 0.967 kg/m → 12 m × 0.967 = 11.61 kg
- Total weld metal: W = 23.2 kg (about 51 lb)
Notice that 12 m of butt weld weighs as much as 40 m of fillet: the groove on thick plate is where the metal goes.
Option A: stick welding (SMAW)
Assumptions: deposition efficiency 60%, deposition rate 1.8 kg/h, operating factor 30%, electrodes 3.0 per kg, power 25 V × 160 A / 0.8 = 5 kW at 0.15 per kWh = 0.75 per arc hour, no gas.
- Electrodes to buy: 23.2 / 0.60 = 38.6 kg → 38.6 × 3.0 = 115.8
- Arc time: 23.2 / 1.8 = 12.9 h; total time: 12.9 / 0.30 = 42.9 h → 42.9 × 12 = 514.7
- Power: 12.9 h × 0.75 = 9.7
- Total: 640.2, or 12.31 per metre of weld and 27.6 per kg of weld metal
Option B: MIG/MAG with 1.2 mm solid wire (GMAW)
Assumptions: deposition efficiency 93%, deposition rate 4.0 kg/h (8 m/min wire feed, as above), operating factor 40%, wire 2.5 per kg, gas 15 L/min = 0.9 m³/h at 4.0 per m³ = 3.6 per arc hour, power 28 V × 250 A / 0.85 = 8.2 kW at 0.15 per kWh = 1.24 per arc hour.
- Wire to buy: 23.2 / 0.93 = 24.9 kg → 24.9 × 2.5 = 62.3
- Arc time: 23.2 / 4.0 = 5.8 h; total time: 5.8 / 0.40 = 14.5 h → 14.5 × 12 = 173.7
- Gas and power: 5.8 h × (3.6 + 1.24) = 28.0
- Total: 264.0, or 5.08 per metre of weld and 11.4 per kg of weld metal
Item | Stick (SMAW) | MIG (GMAW) |
|---|---|---|
Weld metal | 23.2 kg | 23.2 kg |
Consumable to buy | 38.6 kg | 24.9 kg |
Arc time | 12.9 h | 5.8 h |
Total time | 42.9 h | 14.5 h |
Consumables | 115.8 | 62.3 |
Labour and overhead | 514.7 | 173.7 |
Gas and power | 9.7 | 28.0 |
Total | 640.2 | 264.0 |
Cost per metre | 12.31 | 5.08 |
What the numbers tell you
Labour is most of the cost. In the example labour and overhead are 80% of the stick cost and 66% of the MIG cost. The consumable, which is what people usually argue about with the supplier, is a small share. A wire that costs 20% more but runs faster or needs less cleaning almost always pays for itself.
The biggest savings are in the weld size and the operating factor. Hold welds to the size on the drawing (gauges help), use a smaller groove angle or a double-V on thick plate where the procedure allows, and plan the work so welders spend less time waiting for parts or cranes. Positioners and good fit-up raise the operating factor more than any change of consumable.
Gas costs more than power, but both are small. MIG adds 28 for gas and power and still saves more than 370 on this job, because the arc time drops from 12.9 h to 5.8 h and the operating factor improves.
Check your own figures. Every input in the example is a typical value, not a standard. Time a few real joints in your shop, weigh the wire used on a job, and replace the assumptions with your own numbers. A good estimate is only as good as its operating factor.
What the estimate leaves out
The calculation above covers the welding itself. On a full quote you also need to allow for cutting and edge preparation, fit-up and tacking, preheat and post-weld heat treatment where required, back-gouging of double-sided welds, grinding and dressing, inspection (visual, dye penetrant, ultrasonic or radiography), weld procedure and welder qualification, and repairs. On critical work these can add as much again as the welding. The raw steel is priced separately; the steel weight calculator and the plate calculator help with that, and our guide to counting MS and SS sheets for a tank shows how to work out plate quantities. When you send the job out for pricing, list weld sizes, lengths and inspection requirements clearly, as explained in how to prepare a machinery quotation request.
Quick reference formulas
- Fillet weld area: A = z² / 2 (z = leg; z = 1.414 × throat)
- Single-V butt weld area: A = g × t + t² × tan(α / 2)
- Cap allowance: A × 1.15
- Weld metal: m = A × L × ρ (carbon steel: 7.85 g per mm² per metre)
- Consumable to buy: m / η_d
- Arc time: m / D; total time: arc time / operating factor
- Gas: flow (L/min) × 0.06 = m³ per arc hour
- Power: V × I / (1,000 × η_ps) kW per arc hour
- Cost = consumable × price + total time × labour rate + arc time × (gas + power)
To run the numbers for your own joints, use the welding cost estimator. It handles fillet and single-V butt welds for stick, MIG/MAG, flux-cored and submerged arc welding and gives the result in total and per metre. For background on the processes, see the Wikipedia article on gas metal arc welding.