How to prepare a machinery quotation request
A practical guide to writing a request for quotation for plant machinery: state the duty, the site conditions, the scope and the format, so that supplier offers can actually be compared.
Most disappointing machinery purchases do not start with a bad supplier. They start with a vague enquiry. "Please quote for a 10 ton flour mill" can be answered in a dozen honest ways, and the buyer then spends weeks comparing offers that were never for the same thing. A good request for quotation, or RFQ, is a short document that makes every supplier answer the same question. This article sets out what it should contain.
Start with the duty, not the machine
Describe what the plant has to do before you name any equipment. A supplier who knows the duty can propose the right machine; a supplier who is only given a model name will quote that model whether it fits or not. For a process plant the duty usually means:
- Product and raw material. What goes in and what comes out, with the grades or specifications that matter, such as moisture, particle size or purity.
- Capacity and its basis. Tonnes per day of raw material or of finished product, and over how many hours. A 100 tonne per day mill running 20 hours needs different machines from one running 8 hours. State the design capacity and whether you expect to expand.
- Operating conditions. Temperatures, pressures, flow rates, liquid densities and viscosities, steam pressure at the point of use. These are the numbers the sizing tools on MachineryCalc work from, and they are the numbers a supplier needs too.
- Duty cycle. Continuous or batch, seasonal or year-round, and the number of starts per day.
Give the site conditions
Machines are designed for an environment. Leaving this out is the most common reason an offer has to be revised after order. Include:
- Power supply. Voltage, frequency and number of phases, for example 400 V, 50 Hz, three phase, and whether the supply is stable. Mention a generator if the plant will run on one.
- Utilities available. Steam pressure and quantity, compressed air, cooling water temperature, fuel type, water quality.
- Ambient conditions. Maximum and minimum temperature, humidity, dust and altitude. Motors, compressors and cooling equipment are all derated by heat and altitude.
- Space and access. Floor area, headroom, floor loading, crane availability and the largest piece that can get through the door.
- Materials of construction. Say where stainless steel is required, which grade, and where mild steel is acceptable. Food, dairy and chemical duties usually set this.
- Standards and language. Electrical standards, pressure-vessel rules in your country, documentation language and the units you want the offer in.
Define the scope clearly
Two offers for the "same" plant can differ by half because one includes items the other leaves out. Write a scope list and ask each supplier to mark every line as included, excluded or optional:
- Main process machinery, with a numbered equipment list.
- Motors, drives, starters and the control panel.
- Pipework, valves, ducting, conveyors and structural steel between machines.
- Utilities equipment such as boiler, compressor, cooling tower and water treatment.
- Erection, commissioning and trial runs, and who supplies labour, cranes and consumables.
- Training of operators and maintenance staff.
- Commissioning spares and a recommended two-year spares list, priced separately.
- Documentation: general arrangement drawings, foundation loads, electrical drawings, manuals, material and test certificates.
- Packing, transport, insurance and the delivery term you want, such as ex-works, FOB or delivered to site.
Ask for a format that can be compared
Tell suppliers how to lay out the offer. A simple table makes evaluation fast and stops important details hiding in prose:
Column | What it should contain |
|---|---|
Item number | Matches your equipment list |
Description | Function, type, size and capacity |
Make and model | Including bought-out items such as motors, gearboxes and bearings |
Quantity | Units per line |
Installed power | kW per item, for your electrical load estimate |
Material | Contact parts and non-contact parts |
Price basis | Currency, delivery term, taxes included or excluded |
Delivery | Weeks from order or from drawing approval |
Also ask for: performance guarantees with the test method; the warranty period and what it covers; payment terms; the validity of the offer; a list of reference installations of similar size; and the total connected load in kW. Set a date for questions and a date for submission, and send any clarification to every bidder.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Mixed units. Quoting capacity in tonnes per day in one place and bags per hour in another invites errors. Pick one set of units and state it.
- Capacity without hours. A daily figure without the running hours per day is not a capacity.
- No upper limit on power or space. If the supply is 200 kW or the shed is 12 m wide, say so, or the best technical offer may not fit.
- Asking for the cheapest. Ask for the offer that meets the duty at the lowest total cost over its life, including power, spares and downtime.
- Changing the question. If the duty changes during the enquiry, reissue the RFQ to everyone so the offers stay comparable.
A short checklist
- Duty: product, capacity with hours, operating conditions.
- Site: power, utilities, ambient, space, materials, standards.
- Scope: a line-by-line list marked included, excluded or optional.
- Format: an item table, installed power, delivery term, validity, guarantees.
- Process: a question deadline, a submission date, the same answers to every bidder.
Before you send the request, put rough numbers to the duty with the free engineering calculators on MachineryCalc, so that pump heads, motor sizes, tank volumes and boiler duty in your RFQ are already in the right range.